If you’ve picked up a quart or pint of organic ice cream from Straus Family Creamery in the past few weeks, you might want to take a closer look at what’s in your freezer right now.
The Petaluma-based creamery has voluntarily recalled select flavors due to possible metal contamination. The affected products were distributed starting May 4 to retailers across 17 states—including California—in paper cups. That means if you live in the Sacramento area and grabbed a pint of vanilla bean, strawberry, cookie dough, Dutch chocolate, or mint chip ice cream recently, you could have one of the recalled containers at home.
The FDA initiated the recall as a precautionary measure, but the message is clear: don’t take chances. If you own any of these products with best-by dates in late December 2026, the guidance is straightforward—throw it away. Metal contamination isn’t something to gamble with, even if the risk is being taken seriously out of an abundance of caution. Straus Family Creamery’s decision to pull the products reflects the company’s commitment to food safety, but it’s a stark reminder that even trusted organic brands can face unexpected manufacturing hiccups.
The 17 affected states span from Arizona to Wisconsin, which means this is a wide-reaching issue for retailers and customers alike. For Sacramento residents who pride themselves on buying local and organic, this recall hits a bit differently. You’re choosing these products specifically because you trust the sourcing and production standards—and when something like this happens, it shakes that confidence, at least temporarily.
What makes this particularly relevant for our region is that California is one of the states where these products made their way to shelves. If you’ve been stocking your freezer with Straus ice cream as a go-to summer treat, now’s the time to check your supply. Check the UPC codes and best-by dates against the FDA’s list, and if you’ve got a match, don’t hesitate to toss it.
About the Author
Andrew Johnson
Andrew Johnson is a contributor to LocalBeat, covering local news and community stories.
